Winner: Clearly Rachel Bilson. First her shoe choice is much better. We just hate white shoes and they just don't look right with this dress. The length to which the dress is hemmed is also much more flattering on Bilson. With the sweetheart neckline Simmon's necklace is overkill.
Winner: Catherine Zeta-Jones. Even if I were a Playmate, I still wouldn't want to get into the fashion ring with Zeta-Jones. Granted, only 2% of the human population can wear Hervé Légér and about a third of that actually look good in it so kudos to both women. However, Zeta-Jones wins for her minimal choice of accessories. With a dress like this, you don't need many! Silvstedt's coat just doesn't go withthe dress and neither do her shoes and bag.
Winner: I can't believe this upset, but the winner is Carrie Underwood. She is much more pulled together than Klum. But in all fairness, Klum is probably running around shopping and Underwood is most likely going somewhere...camera worthy. Klum always looks amazing, so we will not hold this against her. These are two totally different interpretations.
Winner: Emmy Rossum. TKO. Suede boots with chiffon really makes us cranky, not to mention black suede boots with this light as air frock is just a big, overpowering no! Then again, Cyrus is only 15 so she has time to learn. At least she is dressing more age appropriate here then she has been recently.